Sterling and silver-plated jewelry can look identical in a photo. The difference is what's underneath: sterling is solid silver alloy all the way through, while plated pieces have a thin layer of silver over a cheaper base metal. Here's how to tell them apart.
1. Look for the mark
Solid sterling is usually stamped 925, Sterling, or Ster. Plated pieces are often marked EP, EPNS (electroplated nickel silver), Silverplate, or nothing at all. On Mexican silver, look for 925 alongside a maker's code (see our guide to Mexican silver hallmarks).
2. Try a magnet
Silver isn't magnetic. If a strong magnet grabs the piece, it isn't solid sterling. A piece that doesn't react isn't proven to be silver, though, because many base metals aren't magnetic either. Note that clasps and springs can contain steel, so test the body of the piece.
3. Check the high-wear spots
On plated pieces, the silver layer wears through first on edges, clasps, and the backs of rings. A coppery, yellow, or gray metal peeking through is a strong sign of plating. Sterling stays the same color all the way down.
4. Look at the tarnish
Sterling tarnishes to a soft gray or black, and a polishing cloth brings it back. Plated pieces can tarnish too, but heavy polishing can wear through the plating to the base metal.
5. Feel the weight
A solid sterling bracelet or chain often feels noticeably heavier than a plated piece of the same size. That's why we list weights in grams on many of our heavier pieces.
6. The acid test (what we use)
The most reliable at-home check is a silver acid test: a tiny scratch on an inconspicuous spot and a drop of testing solution, which reacts differently to sterling, lower-grade silver, and base metal. It's how we verify pieces before listing, and when a stamp says 925 but the test disagrees, we put that in the title.
Shop tested sterling
Everything in our Sterling Silver collection has been checked, with marks listed in every title. Looking for something specific? Start with Italian sterling chains or collector's bracelets.